Bad Day Turned Better #1

 Andy was working on some of his writing. He creates stories and shares them online, on different sites. What he writes are small short stories about a fetish he has, which is a bellybutton fetish. It's a cute innocent fetish, that mainly includes tickling. Or just someone touching and poking one's bellybutton. People generally enjoy the content he posts, probably because they appreciate cute things, which is what he tends to write.

He had always wanted to share his fetish with someone. He saw his opportunity when he met someone a while back. A guy named Matthew. Matthew was quite slim, and he had a shallow innie. Once, Andy caught a glimpse of his navel when they were in the locker room about to head to P.E. But even after they started dating, Andy was still nervous and afraid to tell him how he wanted to see his belly button, and over all just wanted to explore his fetish with him.

But one day, he worked up the courage to ask.

"Hey, Matthew? Can I tell you something?" They both were sitting on the bed edge, Matthew was resting his head on Andy's shoulder. 

"Sure cutie, what is it?" Matthew looked up at Andy.

Andy's face turned red, as his mind raced with what he was going to say. "Um... I want to admit something..."

Matthew sat up, then turned his head to Andy. "Uh... ok?"

Andy took a  deep breath, "I... have this fetish... I've been wanting to tell you, but I've been nervous. I have a belly button fetish. I've...always wanted to see and touch yours..." Andy's voice trembled. He had his head down, and for a moment, he didn't hear anything. He eventually looked up, only to see that Matthew had a strange expression on his face. 

".... You have what now?"

"Um... belly button fetish...." Andy repeated softly.

Matthew blinked. "You... get off to bellybuttons? What the fuck?" He asked. 

Andy felt a little hurt. "Um... it's more than th-that," What Andy meant was that it's not about getting off to it. He feels differently about looking at bellybuttons compared to any other part, especially sexual parts. But Matthew misunderstood. 

"You mean, you're a weirdo who likes bellybuttons in such a weird way that it's creepy?" Matthew asked, laughing. His laugh sounded mocking to Andy. Which was strange, because he always loved Matthew's laugh. 

"U-uh..I.." Andy didn't know what to say. But Matthew had plenty.

Matthew shook his head, with a disgusted look, "I can't believe I'm dating a freak."

That was it for Andy. It felt like someone stabbed him in his heart. There's nothing worse than being called a 'freak' for an innocent fetish you're built with. Especially if it's your own boyfriend who says it. Andy felt so hurt that he got up and left the room. "What, you're breaking up with me?" Matthew asked with a snort. "Fine, I don't want to be a boyfriend to a freak anyway," He said.


______________________

It was the next day. Matthew was about to head to school, but first, he had some breakfast. He could barely eat because of what happened the day before. He broke up with his boyfriend over something as simple as a fetish. After he finished, he got up, grabbed his school bag, and headed out the door to get to his 12th grade classes.

He usually walks with his friends or takes the public buses to school, since the school buses for his school don't come to his home. But today, the bus was late. And his friends never showed up, so he just walked.

So, as a result he was a little late when he arrived; his first class of the day had already begun. But luckily there was a substitute teacher who couldn't care less about how many of the students were in the class. Though, when he walked in, he noticed everyone was looking at him, snickering. Everyone except his four friends who shared the first class and P.E with him: Julian, Marcus, Ryan, and Arthur. All four of them were just looking at Andy.

'What's going on?' Andy thought.

Andy also didn't want to be in the class because his boyfriend—well, ex-boyfriend apparently—had the same first period with him. All Andy did was ignore them all and just sit in his seat. The students were still whispering behind him as if they were talking about him. 'What's happening?' He wondered. But he tried to ignore it and just opened his book to work on what he needed to do.

But then he felt someone tap his shoulder. He looked up, then turned his head to see one of his classmates, Adam, trying to get his attention. Andy assumed Adam was going to ask for a pencil or an eraser, because that's how Adam is. Never prepared. Taking a glance at Adam, Andy saw some misty dark substance over his shoulders that quickly vanished. Andy blinked a few times, maybe he was seeing things, he hadn't gotten much sleep last night.

Then, what Adam asked made Andy feel like he wanted to hide.

"Is what Matthew said true? You have some weird bellybutton fetish?"

Andy didn't know what to say, as his face went red with embarrassment. Is that why all the other students were giggling about when he walked in? Did Matthew really take kink shaming that far, that he told the entire classroom?

Adam saw Andy's red face and laughed. "Oh my god, he wasn't lying! You are a freak!" He laughed.

That made Andy feel dead inside. Adam had said what he said really loudly, so the whole class heard him, and they all started to laugh at Andy.

Andy just looked down at his desk, ashamed. He glanced at his four friends, who were just looking at him. They didn't say anything. 'They probably hate me now,' Andy thought, looking back down at his desk.

_____________________________________________

After a few more classes, he had P.E.

Fortunately, first period was the only class he shared with Matthew, so he hadn't seen him since. He walked up the steps to get to the locker room, opened the door and walked in, only to see that no one was inside. 'Where is everyone?' He thought. He turned the corner, only to see his four friends. When Andy saw them, his face went red, because he definitely didn't want to face them after what happened back in class, so he turned around to leave. He didn't care if he was about to miss his nest class.

"Hey, Andy, wait!" Arthur called out to him.

Andy turned back around to see Arthur calling him over. He just sighed and walked over to them. All four of his friends were sitting on a bench. 

Arthur looked amongst their friends, then back at Andy with a sympathetic expression, "Um... just to let you know... we weren't part of...whatever happened back in first period," Arthur told him.

Ryan nodded, similar expression. "Yeah, we weren't."

"Um.... do you want to talk about what really went down? I'm a little confused with all of it," Marcus said. 

Julian nodded. "Yeah, what happened? You can talk to us Andy,"

Andy sighed, rubbing his temples slightly, "I... um... we broke up-,"

Arthur narrowed his eyes, "But why?" Arthur asked.

"Weren't you and Matthew like the school's favorite couple?" Ryan asked. "You guys did everything together,"

"Didn't you hear what he was talking about?" Andy grumbled. They must have heard Matthew going on about his fetish. They were there.

Ryan shook his head, "I find it hard to believe that he broke up with you for a simple fetish like that," he said, looking at Andy. 

Arthur nodded. "Yeah, what gives?"

Andy sighed. "Well, believe it. He called me a freak last night," He turned around to go use the bathroom. "Excuse me... while I go change for P.E," His voice was filled with emotion. He still couldn't get over that had happened. The 4 other boys watched Andy walk off into the in-locker room restroom that was nearby. 

When Andy left, Julian looked at his three friends. "Can't believe that jerk did that to poor Andy," he muttered.

Marcus nodded. "Kink shamers are the worst."

"And it's not even that—he told everyone in the class!" Julian added. "We gotta help Andy somehow-,"

"But how?" Arthur asked. Then he had an idea a second later. "I know! We take off our shirts, so when he comes back from the restroom, he can see our belly buttons, and maybe we can let him touch them. That'll probably make him feel better," Arthur suggested. 

Ryan shrugged. "Sure, I'm down with that. What about you two?" He asked, looking at Marcus and Julian. 

"Sure," they both said.

So all four of them took off their shirts, and tossed them on the bench.

Arthur had a chubby belly with a deep innie bellybutton, Ryan had a slim belly with a coin slot navel, was very deep. Marcus was skinny and had a wide shallow bellybutton, and Julian had an outie.

"I... hope he likes outies..." Julian said as he put his hand on his, as he absentmindedly circled it with his index finger.

Just then, Andy came out of the restrooms. "I guess I'm ready to go to P.E—" He stopped when he saw all four of his friends were shirtless. There was a slight dust of pink on his face, "U-um..." Andy blinked..

All four of his friends blushed. "Um... uh, surprise?" Ryan said with a small giggle.

"Uh... what are you all doing?" Andy stammered.

"We hate what Matthew did to you, so... if you want, you're welcome to play with our bellybuttons..." Ryan said.

Andy's face went red. "Y-you... you... ....what?" 

Arthur giggled at Andy's bashful look.

"Yes, this is real, Andy," Julian said, with a playful eye roll.

"Just... pick one of us first, I guess..." Ryan said quietly.

Andy looked at their bellybuttons. '...Is this happening?' He muttered to himself. He secretly always wanted to properly see his friend's navels too, he would never expect to ever see them.. like this, in this way.

Andy always loves really wide shallow bellybuttons, and that was the one that Marcus had. So he went to touch his. "Ooh~," Arthur said with a giggle. "Seems like Marcus is the first one—"

Andy's face turned extremely red as he put his finger inside Marcus' shallow innie, feeling inside it, poking at the navel knot that was visible and exposed.

Ryan titled his head as he watched, ".... How could Matthew hate a cute face like this?" Ryan asked.

Marcus started to giggle, with his slim skinny belly slightly sucking in as Andy was touching it. "Hehehe... it tickles a little," Marcus smiled. 

"I... think Andy really likes your extremely wide bellybutton," Julian laughed. "Like, it's so big,"

Marcus blushed at Julian's tease, "Shut up... like, he'll like your outie at all—"

Andy's head darted to his ginger haired friend, "... Julian has an outie?" he asked, wide eyes. He took his finger out of Marcus' navel then looked at Julian. 

Julian blushed. "Yeah... it's weird. You probably don't like outies..." He said, putting two fingers on his protruding navel knot and pulled it so it stretched out. "See? It's so weird and flexible,"

Ryan laughed. "You're not even human—"

But then they all saw Andy's face turn tomato red when Julian pulled his outie out.

Julian blinked. "Oh-? Oh my-.. He.. He likes my outie—" Julian giggled.

Andy blushed. "Can... I... touch it?"

Julian playfully rolled his eyes. "Duh... that's why we're here doing this, dummy—"

Andy smiled, then started to play with Julian's outie. He softly moved his finger around the stretchy outie, then pinched it and gently pulled on it, which caused Julian to bite his lip, and he accidentally moaned. Julian gasped, then covered his mouth as his eyes slightly widened.

Ryan snorted, "Whoa...Andy, you're awakening something in Juliy..." he giggled. 

Julian blushed madly, then covered his face. "I-I... um... it slipped out—" He said. Andy blushed with him, and everyone else laughed softy.

"Let's see if he likes mine—" Arthur said. Andy stopped playing with Julian's adorable outie and looked at Arthur's chubby tummy with his very deep innie.

It made Andy's face blush so hard.

"Never in my life knew that someone would like my chubby stomach," Arthur said with a blush. Andy smiled as he poked Arthur's deep innie, his finger going in so far. He could barely feel the knot deep in there. His finger dug inside, trying to feel for it, it was warm and the walls of Arthur's navel wrapped around his finger.

Andy's face went so red as he accidentally got... excited about it.

Arthur and the rest glanced down at Andy's pants, then Arthur blushed extremely hard. 

Andy noticed and quickly took his finger out from the deep belly button. "I'm sorry!" He exclaimed.

"Nah, don't be—" Arthur said. "Man, this is really exciting you, isn't it?" Arthur said.

Andy nodded. "Yeah..." He muttered. He continued to poke at Arthur's really deep navel, wiggling his finger all around inside, feeling the knot and poking deep.

He eventually took his finger out, and he accidentally made a mess in his pants. Everyone giggled. 

"If we were in a bedroom, I'd lick it—" Julian randomly said. 

"Get your horny ass out of here—" Ryan joked. 

Andy had to giggle at that, but then blushed at what Julian said.

"Now...I guess my bellybutton is last—" Ryan said. Andy looked at his slim belly and a somewhat deep innie, despite him being slim. It was a coinslot innie.

Andy went to poke it and put his finger inside, but Ryan was giggling all over the place. 

"Well, someone's ticklish," Julian teased. 

"I can't help it! My belly button is one of my most sensitive spots." Ryan said, between giggles.

All of a sudden, Andy left Ryan's bellybutton and went back to play with Julian's.

Julian blushed and gasped. Arthur giggled. "I think Andy loves Julian's bellybutton more than all of ours."

Andy blushed. "His... is really cute to me," He said. Andy kept pulling on Julian's outie. Andy couldn't believe that he had just experienced his fetish with four different people with different bellybuttons. This day definitely went from bad to good so far. He relished this moment.