You must be 18+ to visit this website
The content on this website is AGE RESTRICTED
Please confirm you are at least 18 years old of age. Otherwise leave the website.
Caliban Darklock profile
Caliban Darklock
18+
Caliban Darklock
Art, music, and game dev
Message

Subscription Tiers

FREE
Subscriber

Free subscription, if you just want to follow my progress.

3 subscribers SubscribeStar $0.00 tier
Unlock
$10
USD monthly
Supporter Tier

Currently nothing extra, but if you really want to give me money I won't complain

0 subscribers SubscribeStar $10.00 tier
Unlock

Features

  • Weekly post on general random thoughts
  • Handy collection of YouTube videos
  • Eventually some exclusives for subscribers, I guess
Caliban Darklock
Public post

The House House Debacle

What is the proper stance here? What does "proper" mean, anyway?

Okay so if you didn't know, the developers of "Big Walk" have admitted that in the final stages of the product, faced with apathy from the Unity dev team, fixed a difficult performance problem in their game by prompting an LLM for what ended up being a ten-line fix in the render pipeline. As I understand it, the LLM wrote them a longer, shittier fix which they examined and analysed before rewriting the conceptual solution in their own, human-produced code.

They revealed this when several judges at the Independent Game Awards announced they would not be voting for any game that used AI in its production at all, in any way, and demanded the disclosure from all entries. "Big Walk" had been favoured for several awards, and House House knew that by saying "we used it for this" they were basically just shooting their chance at an award in the head. They had skin in the game and they just took a deep breath and pulled.

These are four (4) separate incidents that are being treated as one. Each of the above paragraphs is a call-and-response pair.

Unity support was being a bitch, like they do, SO House House turned to an LLM.

The IGA demanded disclosure of even the slightest AI usage, SO House House told people the truth.

For the first half of these, boo Unity and yay IGA.

For the second half, boo House House and also yay House House.

The first pair of situations are two different companies doing two different Bad Things that are bad for two different reasons. The second pair is two different groups taking two different principled moral stances that are principled for two different reasons.

Boo to the Bad Things, yay to the principled moral stances.

Unity's Bad Thing was having a bug in their software and responding to a customer saying "hey you have a bug" with "well file a report and then fuck off."

They did this to me, too, like twelve years ago. See, if you put a 3D CPU particle system over a 2D scene, the particle system's location was reset to the world origin and all angles reset to zero. So my particle system that was supposed to be sitting over a button and blowing out particles for player feedback was instead sitting at the top left corner of the screen blowing out particles to the left, where you couldn't see any of them. I filed a report and spent a week building them a minimal repro case with full analysis of the problem, and then they did jack fucking shit for three months.

So to make progress on my game, I made a blank 3D scene with the particle effect sitting on a black background and recorded my screen to produce a short video of the desired effect, which I then used key transparency to superimpose on the button where I wanted it. Applying a random rotation factor helped make it not-so-obvious that it was the exact same particle effect every time.

This, too, was a Bad Thing. That's a fucking stupid solution. It just brute forces the effect onto the screen by any means necessary, instead of solving the actual problem. But when you have a project that you are trying to ship, sometimes soilving the actual problem is out of your reach, and you have to use brute force to get the job done.

I didn't have an LLM available, and if I did, I would have been a little bitch about it and said "fuck that garbage-farting computer machine" while I wrote the same brute force solution. But I cannot fault House house for fixing a difficult problem with a Bad Thing so they could ship.

We all do it. We all write code we know better than to write, because something must be done or nobody gets paid. Some nonzero number of people are going to use the LLM when they know better than to use it, because they need to ship so they can get paid. If you have a problem with that, you have probably never shipped anything, and with that attitude you never will. Morality, in all cases, is a luxury. When things get bad enough, you will step outside of it.

That brings us to the principled moral stances. I applaud the IGA for a bunch of their judges (not all of them) standing up and saying "we will not vote for any AI-produced game, no matter how small of an amount AI produced." They drew a hard line and said you couldn't cross it. I like that they drew this line, and I like what they drew the line about, I'm on board with all of it. Good job IGA, I'm proud of you.

And now here's House House. Maybe if they had known using the LLM was going to disqualify them from awards, they wouldn't have used it. Maybe they regret that decision now. But their decision was in the past; they had already made it, and they were being asked "what decision did you make?" so they said "this is the decision we actually made" and not "this is the decision we wish we had made, and think we can get away with lying about."

They told the truth when it cost them something. That is a Good Thing, and I like that they did it. Good job House House, I'm proud of you. Not for the decision they made, but for their honesty about making it. That matters. They are setting an example. Using an LLM may cost you awards, but if you used one, you have to own up to using it.

A lot of people don't seem to understand how time works. It does not matter how much you regret the thing you did, or how outraged people are that you did it, now that it is done... it cannot be undone. That happened. That is a thing. You can lie about it, and say it didn't happen, but that doesn't change reality. It still happened. And you're just compounding the Bad Thing you already did with a second Bad Thing of lying about it.

It is objectively better to stick with the one Bad Thing and admit to it. No matter how mad you are at House House for using the garbage-farting computer machine, you would absolutely be madder if they tried to lie about it, especially if they won awards before anyone found out. That's three (3) Bad Things! Probably not before the cock crows, but still. They used the LLM, they lied about using the LLM, and that's how they cheated to win the award. That's clearly worse than just using the LLM.

A lot of pessimistic people are pointing at this and saying "thanks to this bullshit, all the AI users are going to lie about it now so they can still win awards." I don't think so. I think thanks to this principled moral stance, more indie devs will refuse to use the LLM altogether. They will see that winning awards is tied to their decision never to use this bullshit, ever, and they will want to win awards so they won't use it. I think that effect will be much larger than the number of people who say "well, I guess I have to lie about it then."

I mean, they're all stupid and crazy, the people using it. So yeah, all of them are probably going to lie. They're liars and cheats and thieves and thoroughly repulsive people. Of course they are going to do the repulsive thing. They're awful and they suck.

But that's not most people. Most people who build things are very concerned with doing honest work. We bundle the two concepts together for a reason.

So yeah. Fuck you for using the garbage-farting computer machine, House House, but thank you for being honest about it. I don't hate you and I'm not going to go around telling all my friend on the internet for to not for to buy you product. I myself will not buy it because, again, fuck you. But maybe your next project will refuse to use the garbage-farting computer machine, and I might buy that one.

You're not irredeemable. We've all done it. Maybe not with an LLM, but with something.
Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
Caliban Darklock
Public post
https://youtu.be/Tay4AGzOjIQ

Technically this is not work because something something building the temple so not in the 39 melakhot
Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
Caliban Darklock
Public post
https://youtu.be/00zEzN6lL3o

It's harder than you think to clone a game design.
Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
Caliban Darklock
Public post
https://youtu.be/xDAfY4j_Lc0

Branno's latest video was not in alignment with my opinions.
Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
Caliban Darklock
Public post

The Kinship of Flesh

All hail the new flesh, same as the old flesh.

The constant stream of "we are so fucked" from the indie game community continues unabated, as does the constant stream of "you are so fucked" from the garbage-farting computer machine community.

The extortion emails are so funny. "I have committed a crime," they say. "Give me money or I will commit another one." Which is, itself, a crime. It's like reverse blackmail. "You didn't commit a crime, but I did!"

I'm waiting for the first copyright case where they use this email as evidence. "Your Honor, we know the plaintiff committed criminal copyright infringement because they told us themselves." Did you know there's a $250,000 fine for that? Somebody's gonna find out.

The big tell for fake art from the garbage-farting computer machine right now is perspective. You might see an image like this and go "why that looks fine." But an artist immediately clocks that something is off. Something is wrong with this picture. They may not immediately be able to articulate why, but it doesn't feel real.
These look like cubes, but they're not.

If you just draw a few lines, it becomes clear to anyone who knows what perspective is that these edges don't make sense. Lines that should be parallel are clearly not; parallel lines go to the same vanishing point, and vanishing points all sit at the same horizon. These... don't.
They're not even close.

The most damning bit here is the pyramid, which not only has its sides pointing wildly at a lower horizon than the rest of the glass cubes, but the visible far edge of the pyramid through the glass body doesn't even go to the corner of the pyramid. And while it's understandable that the cubes may all be turned slightly differently, the edges of cubes are always parallel to one another. Hence, these are not cubes. They are weird, almost-cube shapes.

In addition, the mirrored surface they sit on... isn't flat. It's subtly wavy, tilting the cubes so they converge on entirely separate horizons. But it reflects the cubes as though it is perfectly flat, which it can't do if it isn't flat. The perspective is telling you things about the image that the lighting is telling you aren't true.

And then there's that pyramid edge, which is just plain wrong. Everything is a mess until you see that and realise this image is fake.

This is, incidentally, the same problem Hitler had with his paintings. Most people will look at this picture and go "it's all right, I guess."
I mean it's not GREAT.

An artist -- especially one deciding whether to let someone into art school -- is going to be absolutely repulsed. What even is this bullshit. 
Didn't done anything right

It's also been observed -- famously in season 1 episode 6 of "Justified," with Robert Picardo making the observation -- that Hitler couldn't paint convincing people because something was always a little off. They didn't go into it in the episode, but what I observe is that he was putting people where people might be, but he didn't seem to understand WHY the people might be there.
What is that guy on the right doing

He would scatter people through his paintings where he thought there ought to be people, mostly to break up large areas of empty space, and it looks like he was told to do this. Like he didn't observe where people went and what they did, he was just told to put some people in, so he sprinkled them around a bit. A bit. Just a bit.

And it interests me slightly to observe that the garbage-farting computer machine, so popular with fascists and fascist sympathisers, should have the same problems with art as the most iconic fascist of all time. Because to them, it's not a problem.

There is a scene in David Cronenberg's 1986 film "The Fly" where Seth Brundle is explaining to Veronica (Did she have a last name? I don't remember her last name) that the steak he's sent through the machine doesn't taste good because "I haven't taught the machine to be made crazy by the flesh, by the poetry of the steak."
This movie hits WAY different in the age of AI.

A dozen years later, Joe Pantoliano would do his iconic scene as Cypher in "The Matrix," where he reflects that he knows the steak is not real and he does not care.
It is, after all, still a steak. Except it's not.

In full, his reflection is "You know, I know this steak doesn't exist. I know that when I put it in my mouth, the Matrix is telling my brain that it is juicy and delicious. After nine years, you know what I realize? Ignorance is bliss."

He doesn't want the steak to be real. He wants not to know that it isn't.

This is fundamentally where all the jackasses who like the garbage-farting computer machine are sitting. They don't understand. They take a bite of a real steak, a steak that didn't come out of the machine, and they're not crazy for the flesh. They don't get the poetry of the steak. They can't hear the secret song at the centre of the world.

When they give you the nasty, synthetic, foul-tasting steak that you instantly know is not a steak, but some kind of twisted imitation of a steak... they don't understand why you don't accept it as juiicy and delicious, when the garbage-farting computer machine is clearly telling you so.

They asked for a juicy and delicious steak, after all, and this is what the machine farted out. It must be juicy and delicious; the computer said so. If you think it is not juicy and delicious, you are wrong. Trust the computer. The computer is your friend. You must not understand what juicy and delicious really means. You must be jealous. You must be afraid that nobody will want your juicy and delicious steak anymore, because this juicy and delicious steak is free.

The machine can't make art because the people who made the machine can't make art. And then they gave the machine to other people who can't make art, telling them it can make art, and when we say it hasn't made art... they don't understand.

But flesh recognises flesh. If you understand art, if you hear the song, if you get the poetry, if you're made crazy, you see the artistry. You recognise it. You know that this is from someone who is just like you in certain important ways.

And if it came from a machine, it's not. You can tell before you can explain. You feel that connection with the artist, deep down, and with the machine there's just... nothing there. 

Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
Caliban Darklock
Public post
https://youtu.be/pNSU-KOVc38

I mean this is about as basic as it gets
Like(0)
Comments  loading...
Sign Up or Log In to comment on this post
View next posts (6 / 298)
WE USE COOKIES

SubscribeStar and its trusted third parties collect browsing information as specified in the Privacy Policy and use cookies or similar technologies for analysis and technical purposes and, with your consent, for functionality, experience, and measurement as specified in the Cookies Policy.

Your Privacy Choices

We understand and respect your privacy concerns. However, some cookies are strictly necessary for proper website's functionality and cannon be denied.

Optional cookies are configurable. Disabling some of those may make related features unavailable.

We do NOT sell any information obtained through cookies to third-party marketing services.